It wasn't pleasant to local businessmen that their market was entered by the capital company.
On October 13 the Economic court of the Nikolaev area nullified competition on the right of garbage removal from one of key areas of the regional center. At competition the Grinko — Nikolaev company close to the Kiev businessman Alexander Griban won. The Nikolaev competitor of the capital businessman - JSC Nikspetsservice became the initiator of trial.
The local company "Nikspetsservice" decided to extend the sphere of the influence on one of four districts of the city - Factory.
Such conclusion it is necessary to recognize from the petition of this enterprise in court invalid results of competition on TBO export from this area which was carried out by local administration in January, 2009. Following the results of auction of that time by the winner JSC Grinko-Nikolaev belonging to the Kiev JSC Grinko of the capital businessman Alexander Griban was recognized. In "Nikspetsservice" consider that this decision was illegal for several reasons. In - the first, when carrying out competition his organizer - administration of the Factory area - didn't provide to all participants of the tender competitive documentation. In - the second, competition was held earlier 30-day term from the date of the publication of the corresponding announcement. "Thus organizers didn't consider that his winner, "Grinko - Nikolaev", in day of carrying out competition had no tariff coordinated by the Executive Committee of the City Soviet of People's Deputies for services in export of household waste", - reported in "Nikspetsservice".
In administration of the Factory area this information disprove, approving in court the return: all participants of competition were acquainted with its conditions on receipt, the current legislation doesn't provide obligatory coordination of a tariff for services in TBO export for participation in competition. "Competition was really held before the term established by the law (30 days.) but it was made to provide continuousness of garbage removal", - reported in administration of the Factory district of Nikolaev.
Despite these statements, on October 13 Economic court of the Nikolaev area I decided to meet the requirement of "Nikspetsservice" and to recognize illegal competition thanks to which "Grinko - Nikolaev" had an opportunity to work in the Factory area. As reported in "Grinko - Nikolaev", the company together with administration of the Factory area will challenge this verdict. "In "Nikspetsservice" consider that when carrying out competition procedures weren't observed, but we consider that everything was lawful. We already submitted the appeal in the Odessa appellate economic court. Date of consideration isn't defined yet", - the legal adviser "Grinko - Nikolaev" Yulia Didovets reported.
In Nikolaev dozen of enterprises which rigidly compete among themselves in the territory of all four districts of the city is engaged in export of solid household waste. Between the majority of them there is a continuous war for rendering services in export of household waste. It became known of one of the last oppositions in August, 2009 when the Antimonopoly committee of Ukraine fined the municipal enterprise "Nikolayevkommuntrans" 5 thousand UAH for unfair competition. The matter is that "Nikolayevkommuntrans" addressed with letters to clients of the competitor of JSC Nikspetsservice, having distributed information that this open company is liquidated.
The competition between garbage carriers in Nikolaev became aggravated at the end of last year when above-mentioned JSC Grinko-Nikolaev for the first time entered the "garbage" market of the city. To the companies specializing on this activity, is for what to be overcome: annually the city "makes" about 1 million cubic meter of garbage which needs to be taken out on the range. If to consider that now the tariff for services in TBO export for inhabitants of Nikolaev (for the population and state employees) makes about 25 UAH/m3, leave that annually on garbage removal it is possible to earn more than 25 million UAH